Guide
A customer downgraded or cancelled and Stripe gave them a credit, not a refund. Where the money is, why your next payout is smaller, and how to book it
A customer moved from your $100 plan to your $10 plan halfway through the month. Stripe didn't refund anything. Their next invoice came out at $0, the customer emailed asking where their money went, and next month's payout is $90 lighter than your subscriber count says it should be. Nothing is broken. Stripe parked the difference on the customer's credit balance, and it will keep using it until it runs out.
What Stripe does when a plan goes down
Stripe's support article uses this exact case. A customer on a $100 a month price moves to a $10 a month price in the middle of the billing cycle. They are owed $50 for the unused half of the old price and owe $5 for the rest of the month on the new one, so Stripe owes them $45. That $45 is added to the customer's credit balance to be applied to future invoices. The same can happen when a subscription is cancelled with proration. Stripe says plainly that refunding the credit to the original card does not happen automatically.
Where to find the balance
Open the customer in the Stripe Dashboard and look for Customer invoice balance. Stripe's documentation says the invoice balance and the customer credit balance are two names for the same thing. Click View details to see each line that built it: a proration credit, a credit note, a manual adjustment, or an invoice the credit was applied to. Each entry is a permanent record, so the history always adds up to the balance shown. This balance is not your Stripe balance, not billing credits for metered usage, and not the cash balance that bank transfer customers have. Stripe tracks those separately.
What it does to the next invoices
By default the balance applies to the next invoice Stripe finalizes for that customer, in the same currency, up to the invoice total. A $45 credit against a $10 renewal makes the next four invoices $0 and the fifth one $5. A $0 invoice is marked paid without charging the card, so there is no charge, no fee, and nothing from that customer in your payout. The credit also does not apply to invoices created by Checkout Sessions with invoice creation turned on.
Why your payouts look short
Your revenue report may count the customer as active at $10 a month. Your payouts will show nothing from them until the credit is used up. If several customers downgraded in the same month, the gap between subscriptions and money that actually hit your bank can last a while. It is timing, not missing money: the cash came in earlier, in the payout that carried the original $100 charge. Check the customer's balance history before you chase the gap anywhere else.
If you would rather refund the card
Some customers want the money back, not credit. Stripe's support steps: find the customer's balance, list the invoices for that subscription, and refund the most recent charges up to the balance. If one charge is smaller than the balance, refund all of it and carry the rest to the next charge. Then set the balance back to zero, by adjusting it on the customer page or through the API. Skip that last step and the customer gets the money twice: once as a refund, and again as free invoices. A refund comes out of your next payout, and Stripe keeps the processing fee on the original charge. To avoid a balance in the first place, turn proration off when you change the plan, or issue a credit note with a refund instead of a credit.
How to book it in QuickBooks or Xero
The original $100 was recorded as revenue when it was charged. The $45 credit means you now owe the customer $45 of service or cash. A common approach is to record that as a customer credit liability, not as a refund and not as nothing. Each $0 invoice then uses up part of the credit: move $10 from the liability to revenue. If you refund the credit instead, the refund reduces the liability and goes through your Stripe clearing account like any other refund. Small businesses on cash basis often skip the liability and record the refund when it happens. Ask your accountant which fits your books. Either way, leave the original sale alone.
Catch it before month-end
Conciliq reads your Stripe account every morning with a read-only key, rebuilds each payout from its balance transactions and tells you whether it is Matched, Timing or needs a look. When a payout is smaller than your subscriptions suggest, you can see which charges are in it and which customers had no charge that day, so a credit balance stops looking like missing money.
Check yours
Does the money Stripe paid you match your books?
Upload a Stripe export or paste a read-only key. Every payout in the last 90 days, matched to the cent, usually in under a minute. Nothing stored.
Run the free audit →Questions people ask
- Does Stripe refund the customer automatically when they downgrade?
- No. Stripe's support article says the downgrade credit is added to the customer's credit balance and applied to future invoices. Refunding it to the original payment method is something you do yourself.
- Does the customer credit balance expire?
- No. Stripe's documentation says an invoice balance adjustment has no expiration. It sits on the customer until an invoice uses it or you adjust it to zero.
- Why did a customer's invoice show $0 and no payment?
- Most often their credit balance covered it. Stripe applies the balance to the next finalized invoice up to its total, and a $0 invoice is marked paid without charging the card, so nothing from that customer appears in your payout.
More guides
- Why your Stripe payout doesn't match your sales (and how to check it)
- QuickBooks' Stripe connector imports payouts, not fees. Here is what that does to your books
- Stripe payout breakdown: what every line inside a payout means
- Why a Stripe refund comes out of a later payout
- How a Stripe dispute hits your payout, and how to record it in your books
- A customer's card expires before their next Stripe renewal. What happens, and what to do
- Stripe debited your bank account. Why your balance went negative, and how to book it
- Stripe says the payout is Paid, but the money isn't in your bank. What each payout status means, and what to do
- How to reconcile Stripe payouts in Xero: what Xero matches on its own, and what it can't
- Stripe put a reserve on your account. What it does to your payouts, when the money comes back, and how to book it
- A Stripe renewal was declined. What do_not_honor, insufficient_funds and the other decline codes mean, and what to do about each
- You charged in euros or pounds and Stripe paid you in dollars. Where the conversion fee went, and how to reconcile it
- Your Stripe 1099-K is bigger than the money that hit your bank. Why, and how to tie it to your books
- When does Stripe pay you? The payout schedule, the first-payout wait, and what each setting does to your books
- How to record Stripe payouts and fees in QuickBooks Online by hand: the clearing account method, step by step
- How to read Stripe's payout reconciliation report: what each section means, which download to use, and how to tie every deposit to your books
- Your Stripe payout includes sales tax you owe. How to record it in QuickBooks, and why Stripe's tax report won't match your deposits
- A customer paid a year upfront through Stripe. How to record it in QuickBooks so one month doesn't look like a record
- Stripe sent an early fraud warning. Should you refund the charge or wait, and what each choice does to your payout
- Why your Stripe fees are more than 2.9% + 30¢, and how to find what each extra charge is
- A Stripe ACH payment looked paid, then failed days later. Why it happens, what it does to your payout, and how to book it
- A customer paid a Stripe invoice by check or bank transfer. How to mark it paid, why it never shows up in a payout, and how to book it
- You gave a customer a Stripe coupon. What it does to the charge, the fee and the payout, and how to record the discount in QuickBooks
- A Stripe refund failed. Where the money went, why your payout is suddenly bigger, and how to get the customer paid
- Hundreds of small Stripe payments failed overnight. What a card testing attack is, what to do first, and what it does to your payouts and books
- QuickBooks shows double your Stripe income. Why the sync app and the bank feed both recorded it, and how to fix it
- Stripe says a subscription is incomplete, past due, unpaid or paused. What each status means for the customer, your payouts and your books
- You took Stripe Capital financing and your payouts got smaller. How the repayment works, and how to record it in QuickBooks or Xero
- You took a Stripe Instant Payout and now nothing reconciles. How to match instant payouts, their fee and the smaller payouts after them
- Stripe fee calculator: what your payouts really cost