Check your own payouts free. Every Stripe payout in the last 90 days, matched to the cent. Nothing stored. Run the check →

Guide

A Stripe refund failed. Where the money went, why your payout is suddenly bigger, and how to get the customer paid

You refunded a customer $340 at the end of October. It came out of your next payout, as refunds do. Three weeks later a payout is $340 bigger than the sales inside it, and the customer emails to say they never got their money. The refund failed, and Stripe gave it back to you.

Most refunds to old cards don't fail

A closed or expired card is not usually a problem. Stripe's documentation says refunds to expired or canceled cards are handled by the card issuer and, in most cases, credited to the customer's replacement card; with no replacement, the issuer usually pays the customer another way, such as a check or a bank deposit. Failures are rare. They are more common on bank debits like ACH or SEPA, where a closed bank account sends the money straight back.

What each failure reason means

Stripe marks the refund Failed and records a reason. expired_or_canceled_card: the card was canceled or expired and the issuer would not take it. lost_or_stolen_card: the original card was reported lost or stolen. declined: Stripe's banking partners declined it. insufficient_funds: your own Stripe balance could not cover a card refund, so it sat pending and then ran out of time, which means it is your balance, not the customer's card. charge_for_pending_refund_disputed: the customer disputed the charge while the refund was still pending. merchant_request: you canceled the refund. unknown: the bank gave no reason.

Where the money goes, and when

The bank returns the amount to Stripe, and Stripe adds it back to your Stripe balance. Stripe says this can take up to 30 days from the date the refund was posted. The returned amount then rides out in your next payout as a positive line, linked from the refund's failure_balance_transaction. The refund itself was already taken from an earlier payout, so you now have one short deposit and, weeks later, one deposit that is bigger than the charges and fees inside it.

How you find out

In the Dashboard the payment's timeline shows the refund as failed with its reason. In the API the refund's status changes to failed and Stripe sends a refund.failed event. If nothing in your setup listens for that event, the first sign is often the customer asking where their money is, or a payout that is larger than its sales.

Getting the customer paid

Stripe can only send a refund back to the original payment method, so you cannot retry it to a different card. Stripe's instruction is to arrange another way to pay the customer: a bank transfer or a check from your business account, after confirming the details with them in writing. Keep the refund ID and failure reason with the record. One exception: if the reason is charge_for_pending_refund_disputed, the customer has already opened a dispute. Do not pay them again by hand. Accept or challenge the dispute instead, or they may be paid twice.

A worked example in QuickBooks

On 30 October you refund $340. If you use a Stripe clearing account, you recorded the refund as a reduction of revenue and $340 out of the clearing account, and the payout of 2 November was $340 short. On 20 November the refund fails and $340 comes back. In QuickBooks, record $340 into the Stripe clearing account against a liability account called something like Refunds owed to customers. It is not new revenue: you still owe the money. When you send the customer a $340 bank transfer, record it from your bank account against that same liability, which brings it back to zero. The payout of 24 November now matches: charges, minus fees, plus the $340 that came back.

What to check if the reason is insufficient_funds

This one is about your account, not the customer's. A card refund waits while your available Stripe balance is too low to cover it, and fails if the balance stays short. It usually follows a week of heavy refunds or disputes, or a reserve. Top up the balance or wait for new charges, then issue the refund again; the customer is still owed the money.

Catch it in the payout

A returned refund is easy to miss because it makes a payout bigger, and nobody complains about a bigger deposit. Conciliq reads your payouts each morning with a read-only key, lists every line inside each one and names the returned refund in the payout it lands in, so you see it the day it arrives and can pay the customer before they have to ask.

Check yours

Does the money Stripe paid you match your books?

Upload a Stripe export or paste a read-only key. Every payout in the last 90 days, matched to the cent, usually in under a minute. Nothing stored.

Run the free audit →

Questions people ask

Does Stripe return the processing fee when a refund fails?
No. Stripe keeps the processing fee from the original charge when you refund, and that does not change if the refund later fails. Only the refunded amount comes back to your balance.
How long does it take for a failed Stripe refund to come back?
Stripe says up to 30 days from the date the refund was posted. It then goes out in your next payout like any other money in your balance.
Can I resend a failed Stripe refund to a new card?
No. Stripe only refunds to the original payment method. Pay the customer another way, such as a bank transfer or check, and record it against the amount you owe them.

More guides